I have to make what is probably the hardest decision I’ll ever have to make. One that could cost me my life.
When I had the consultation for my March round of immunotherapy I asked if I could have a face to face consult with my oncologist. I wanted to air my thoughts of just having been treading water for the last year or so and whether I had to just put up with the continual chronic fatigue and occasional minor side effects or whether there was another option.
Most of the time I’ve managed it well but every now and then it got me down and resulted in the post I made at the start of the year. I have to start living again and stop just existing and counting down the days between each round of immunotherapy.
I knew the Nivolumab was working as well as anyone could have hoped for. It (along with 4 cycles of Ipilimumab) had killed off all the visible tumours and was stopping it from coming back (for now). It had already spread from the primary location, my right kidney, to my lungs when it was first discovered.
Stage 4 Kidney cancer prior to immunotherapy had a bleak outlook but things have changed. The problem is my treatment is so “bleeding edge” that there is no data on survival rates or recurrence of tumours. I am the data.
So at the end of March I sat in a small consulting room with Katie at St Lukes Cancer Centre in Guildford having a very honest discussion with my oncologist.
I mentioned the underlying fatigue that has been holding me back as well as other minor side effects such as muscle aches, stomach cramps and diarrhoea.
He reminded me of the crazy NHS rule in the UK where if you stop Nivolumab treatment you cannot start it again. We had to find out if it was a contributor.
I found that a strange statement but he went on to tell us that the Ipilimumab that I had for just 4 cycles right at the start was “disease modifying”. It actually made permanent changes to cancer cells in my body and how my immune system reacted to them. It was quite possible this was causing fatigue, in which case stopping treatment wouldn’t help any way.

We eventually decided that I would take a short treatment break. I can take up to two of these at once and then continue the treatment afterwards. I was going to miss the March treatment and the April treatment. Then after the 8 weeks we should have information to help us make a decision.
Again, I was confused. What decision was there to make? The treatment is keeping me alive and keeping the cancer at bay. Surely if I stop treatment then that cancer will come back?
He dismissed that as something I shouldn’t worry about. If, and it is a a big IF, the cancer came back, it would be detected quickly as I’d be on 3 monthly CT scans. Early detection would mean better prognosis, lots of other medical treatments, removal options were available.
I didn’t say it at the time but I really DID NOT ever want to be told “we found something on your scan” again. That moment in September 2020 when I was sitting alone in A&E at Frimley Park Hospital and a rather sheepish young doctor came in to tell me they’ve found something on my chest x-ray is burned permanently in my brain. It was THE single worst thing I have ever been told.
The feeling of dread, your pulse rushing so fast you can hear it, the cold sweats , the tunnel vision is horrible and something I never want to have to experience again.
So regardless of what happens during the treatment break I will return to it at the end right? RIGHT?
I had my first 4 week follow up with the oncologist today. 4 weeks since I should have had my March treatment and 8 weeks since my last treatment. He asked how things were going.
Well the truth is I have been feeling better. I have a bit more energy every day. I’m having less side effects. This last weekend I was able to do some activity both days, morning and afternoon with a short rest in between. I couldn’t manage that before. I was limited to one thing then wiped out for the rest of the day.
Katie has said she’s seen a difference in me. Less groggy, more “with it”
So I told him the truth.
He immediately said “It seems like we should stop the Nivolumab then”
Wait! What? No. Again pulse racing, cold sweats, trying to concentrate on the phone call and listen to what he was saying.
Good response…..no reason to worry…detected early….
I asked if I had a say in the path forward or if it was just his decision and he confirmed I have a say but he reiterated that it seems that the Nivolumab was holding me back now and that its time to move on. There are still lots of treatment options.
“We found something in your scan” …. I can’t do that again. Can I?
We compromised. We will wait another 4 weeks to my next consult at the end of May where we will discuss again and then make a decision. That will be 12 weeks since my last treatment and the longest I can go and start back on Nivolumab

Red or Blue
Take the red pill and carry on with the Nivolumab, knowing it’s causing some of the fatigue and that I could feel better and get busy living if I stopped it. However no one knows how long it will keep the cancer at bay.
Take the blue pill and stop the nivolumab, get my energy levels up, start enjoying life properly again. Continue with 3 monthly CT Scans. Risk the cancer coming back and having to start new treatments, new side effects, “other” outcomes. Being told “We found something…”
I don’t like risks. With Cancer there are always risks. Its a big decision to make.